Landscape soils and surface environments - Week 6 Workshop 2a
2026-03-24
1 – Carbon:
2 – Nitrogen:
By the end of this workshop, you will be able to:
Explain why P has no atmospheric pool and why P limitation is persistent
Describe how P sorption to Fe/Al oxides locks P away in old WA soils
Compare Banksia cluster roots vs Jarrah mycorrhizae as P-access strategies
Apply C:P stoichiometry to predict immobilisation vs mineralisation
Discuss how cultural burning affects P cycling differently from N
Phosphorus (P): essential for
No atmospheric P pool — entirely from rock weathering
Ancient, weathered Australian soils often chronically P-limited
Key contrast with C and N
No gaseous losses from P.
Recovery: P in centuries (weathering), C in years–decades (NPP), N in decades (fixation),
Fe/Al oxide surfaces carry positive charges at typical WA soil pH
Dissolved PO₄³⁻ binds tightly to these surfaces
Initially adsorbed (reversible) → progressively occluded (irreversible)
Result: total P can be moderate but available P is tiny (< 5 mg/kg)
Syers and Cornforth (1983)
| Aspect | Carbon | Nitrogen | Phosphorus |
|---|---|---|---|
| Source | Atmosphere (CO₂) via NPP | Atmosphere (N₂) via fixation | Rock weathering only |
| Mobility | Respired as CO₂, leached as DOC | High (NO₃⁻ leaches) | Low (sorbs to minerals) |
| Main losses | Respiration, fire, erosion | Leaching, denitrification, fire | Erosion, runoff |
| Recovery | Years–decades (via NPP) | Decades (via fixation) | Centuries (weathering) |
P limitation is harder to reverse than N limitation
No atmospheric pool, no biological fixation — once lost, recovery depends on weathering.
Deep Bassendean sands: very low total and available P
Cluster (proteoid) roots:
High P resorption from leaves (>80%)
Lambers et al. (2014)
Laterites: moderate total P, but strongly sorbed
Jarrah forms ectomycorrhizal (ECM) and arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) associations
Mycorrhizal strategy (ECM + AM):
Deep roots access P from less-weathered horizons
Banksia — cluster roots
Jarrah — mycorrhizal networks
Soil C:P is an ecological indicator of P availability and microbial activity.
Mineral topsoils C:P 10s to a 100s → varies strongly by ecosystem and depth.
Typical patterns in the SCP sand–laterite–pasture gradient (approximate):
Microbial biomass: around C:P ≈ 60:1
When litter C:P is much higher:
When litter C:P is closer to 60:1:
P limitation is usually stronger
In native WA litter, C:P is much higher than 60:1, so microbes tend to immobilise P strongly.
Microbial requirement: C:P ≈ 60:1
Banksia, C:P = 1200
Jarrah, C:P = 900
Pasture, C:P = 400
All three systems immobilise P, but strength differs: Banksia > Jarrah > pasture. Fertiliser- derived P pool in pastures makes microbes less P‑limited → immobilisation is weaker.
For each system (Banksia, Jarrah, pasture):
Part (i) (5 min)
– Fill in the Notes column
What drives the litter and soil C:P patterns?
P conservation strategies, fertiliser inputs
Part (ii) (10 min)
– Predict immobilisation vs mineralisation
Compare litter C:P to microbial C:P ≈ 60:1
Classify: microbial P limitation (low/med/high)
Classify: P loss risk if fertiliser added (low/med/high)
Answer the two short questions
- Which system most strongly immobilises inorganic P?
Which system has higher available P and loss risk?
How do C:P patterns help explain:
P is not volatilised by fire (unlike N and C)
Ash redistributes P locally → temporary increasing available P
Cultural burning:
Part (iii) on your handout (can complete for homework):
P availability controls carbon storage
Low P → limits NPP and litter inputs (\(I\) in \(\Delta C = I - kC\))
High litter C:P → strong P immobilisation → limits nutrient cycling
P limits C storage even when N is adequate → co-limitation
P cannot be replenished biologically → unlike N (fixation) or C (NPP), recovery requires geological weathering (centuries+)
You’ve seen how C, N, and P each limit C storage in different ways; Next workshop we put them together in full CNP stoichiometry.
P has no atmospheric pool; in old WA soils, P is strongly sorbed to Fe/Al oxides, so P limitation is persistent and hard to reverse.
Banksia cluster roots (organic acids + phosphatases) and Jarrah mycorrhizae are specialised strategies that tightly conserve and access P under chronic limitation.
Litter C:P >> microbial C:P (much larger mismatch than for C:N), so microbes usually immobilise P strongly during decomposition, especially in native systems.
Fire does not volatilise P; cultural burning redistributes P via ash and creates short‑lived fertility “hot spots” while largely conserving P at landscape scale.
Next: We integrate C, N, and P as a coupled system.